Tuesday, April 8, 2014

Writing feedback

“Leader Creon”
This paper sounds like a creative writing paper where students were asked to add on to the story by writing what characters would say.  The student wrote from the heart but did not follow the general plot of the story. I saw signs where the student sounded excited about the context and tone was obvious in the writing. Words like “also” could have been omitted to give better flow to the paper.  All of the new twists in the story were very creative and I would recommend for the student to re-direct their energy towards a more accurate account of the story plot. To help the student’s writing I would go over transition words and AAAWUBBIS.


“Antigone”
This writer had good sentence variety and it provided flow to their writing style. I saw experimentation with sentence variety when the writer would use short sentences like “I will do it no more” to average sentence length questions. While this writer had a strong sentence structure and editing skills, I would recommend a lesson where new vocabulary words are encouraged to be used in a student’s writing.


“Haemon”
This piece of writing certainly has voice and a clear organization; all of the events and details that the writer includes lead up to the main clash between Haemon and his father. Transitional words, complex sentences, and commas are the areas where the student could have improved. I noticed that this student was trying to transition onto another idea when they said “Though this is not right.” The student could have said, “While this is not right,” and created a complex sentence to develop his ideas. This is good because it means that the students is aware of transitions and only needs the vocabulary/comma proficiency to be able to include them in their writing. I would also use AAAWUBBIS for this student’s development of transitions and complex sentences.



These three papers show creativity and enthusiasm. Most of them could use better diction and transitions, so I would use graphic organizers to show students how to include them in their writing. 

No comments:

Post a Comment