When reading Enrique's journey I couldn't understand how the journalist continues to believe that we should be a "closed" borders nation. I also do not agree with her purpose--which she states as discouraging mothers from leaving their children behind. In all honesty, I'm not sure how this could be productive. Rather than making arguments against NAFTA, or the extreme poverty and corrupt leaders in Central America, the journalist seems to normalize discourse where women are blamed for the burdens of their children. When Lourdes would defend herself against her son (in their many fights), she states that his dad's family was as much responsible for him as she was.
Additionally, while I am able to have solidarity for Enrique, I was a little bothered by the mysogyny he presented. I didn't like how he manipulated Maria Isabel to make the trip to the USA because he was scared she would find another man. Not only does it make the assumption that she needs to find a man, but it also shows Enrique's own insecurities (born out of masculinity). When arguing with his mom Enrique states, "A true mother, he tells Lourdes, isn’t the person who carries you in her womb. It is someone who raises and nurtures you. He tells her his true mother is his grandmother MarĂa. He misses the beans and spaghetti she made for him" (p. 170). Again, we don't know how much dialogue is true, but this shows Enrique's and the Journalists' own purposes. Enrique couldn't cope with his mom leaving him because he was taught to expect a mother who cooks and nurtures. This is an unfair (and exploitative) expectation on Lourdes, and we read this scene as something that shouldn't go without further development. However, I appreciated the journalists' efforts in highlighting the domestic labor that is expected of women. One scene writes, "The men don’t help with what they consider to be “women’s work.” When Lourdes arrives home from a full day’s work, the kitchen trash container is full, the floors are dirty, and she must cook and clean for everyone" (p. 189). When I was growing up I saw this play out in my own family. My mom would come home from her many odd jobs (housekeeper, nanny, fruit factories) and my dad would complain if she didn't cook. Maybe because I have always had an interesting relationship with gender I was the only one who helped out with cleaning and cooking, but i find it necessary to bring these issues to light.
Another area where I felt as if things could have been smoother (or rather, more critical) is where a lot of blame is placed on African American gangsters. There is a quote where Jasmin says something along the lines of "we are moving because the African Americans are killing hispanics." This depiction is very common in mainstream society, and I don't know why we also don't realize that people of color as a whole live under extreme poverty. Not to excuse gang violence, but this is dangerous discourse that has enabled the police to kill black men (and women, and qpoc people at much higher rates).
Nevertheless, the book reports on very real issues (such as the deportation process of Enrique, and Jasmin's own fear of her parents being deported one day). I do think that even with the failures of this text, I would hope to teach this in a classroom where students have never questioned anti-immigrant anti-refuge feelings of this nation. I give this book an A++
p.s. if you want to check out a "hollywood" version of this text, there is a film titled "under the same moon" (story where the son goes to the US to look for his mom). Here is a trailer:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9jCZgUiPixE
English 325
Tuesday, December 8, 2015
Tuesday, December 1, 2015
After reading Boy Meets Boy I was discouraged from reading another text where the queer characters are white. However, Steve Kluger does an excellent job in writing a novel that touches on many themes in the lives of young adults. Usually there is a tendency for LGBT YA texts to produce a "coming out" rhetoric--where coming out is something that is "normal," should be done, and is acceptable. Kluger's characterization of Augie provides a different account. Instead of creating a novel where all events are leading up to the "coming out scene," Augie's dad remarks, "I still wish he’d talk to us about it, but maybe that’s not really necessary after all. I mean, it’s so Meet the Parents obvious that he thinks he’s bringing home a prospective son-in-law for us, what’s left to discuss?"(Kindle Locations 1322-1324). This simple, yet telling, response could be Kluger's advice for parents with LGBT children. It could also serve as a narrative for LGBT youth to imagine different possibilities. I bring this up because queer youth of color have different relationships to "coming out" narratives, where the "coming out" scene is not necessary due to cultural differences. We do see the standard coming out scene with Andy, but at least we are given a different alternative with Augie.
My Most Excellent Year truly embodies intersectional scholarship where Kluger attends to LGBT, Feminist, and Diability contexts. What I also found most impressive is Kluger's use of feminist critiques. I have written before on the racist and sexist characterizations on Asian American Women, but Kluger offers a different narrative where Augie's mom is a successful writer. I saw feminist and queer traditions of mentorship where she encourages Alejandra, another woman of color, to perform in the talent show. She writes, "There’s no time between now and curtain to discuss the hundred reasons why, but your father’s expectations shouldn’t have anything to do with it. Trust me when I tell you that women stopped living under the repressive thumb of a patriarchal autocracy..." (Kindle Locations 1418-1421). While I commend the usage of "feminist solidarity" among women of color, and Alejandra not being bound by the rule of her father, I will say that this passage takes up themes of postfeminism. By claiming that women have "stopped" living under patriarchy, one assumes that feminism isn't necessary any longer--and that patriarchy is over. This is a very dangerous slippage of Kluger, especially when the narrative is given through the words of women of color. He does a better job in other scenes where Alejandra tells Augie to make Andy say her name right. While minimal, chopping up someone's name repeatedly is a racist micro aggression. It also shows that Alejandra is able to stand up for herself.
I do wish Kluger would have given more commentary on some things. For one, during the thanksgiving celebration the dad says, "We’re having about twenty people over for Thanks-giving on Thursday, so there’ll be enough food for the entire Colonial Army"(Kindle Locations 1816-1817). There is so much potential in this quote to make a critique of the racist (and cruel) celebration that Thanksgiving embodies. I also think that sometimes readers could see Alejandra as a "man hating" feminist, which is not the point about feminism. For example, when she leaves the definition of "stalker" for Anthony, it is brushed off. However, I do think that Anthony's relentless attempts at "getting" with Alejandra speaks to his male privilege. And Kluger could have really expanded on "stalking," a very serious issue that some teenagers might deal with.
In conclusion, there is much more that I would like to write about this novel. I'm usually not one for "happy" novels, but for the purpose of teaching young adults I would happily include this text in any syllabus. The adolescents in the novel show compassion with one another (as in the case of Hucky). One critique of the novel I would make is that back in the 50s and 60s, lesbian novels would have to have a tragic ending for queer characters in order to be published. So I wonder why Anthony and Alejandra were able to maintain their relationship, while Augie and Andy had to break up. I also make this comment because I thought they had a cute story. I give this book A++
Thursday, November 12, 2015
Queer Utopia: For the gays, For the White, and For the Privileged
Don't get me wrong--I am a sucker for romance. When Noah gives flowers to Paul I was the first to text my boyfriend and ask him where my flowers were at. However, and it is a big HOWEVER, I would never teach this book in tri-cities. Not because of the queer content, I wouldn't teach this book because I know my queer students would call me out for feeding them a white text. Where I'm from, we don't have parents who are dentists or nice houses with an art studio. Pasco High School has evacuations on a weekly basis because there is usually a shooting nearby. We have teachers who look away when they find pot, and we also have a gay club that is 90% Latin@. If I were to teach this book I would focus on Infinite Darlene and her gender transgressions. I'm not sure if she is transgender, and I like that. This is the only character I liked because she really fucks with gender. We usually hear of a transgender girl who is very femme and likes boys, but Infinite Darlene is different because she can be femme and she can also be a quarterback. In a way I thought she was genderqueer--haven't finished reading the book so I'm hoping the author works more with this concept. As I read this book I was excited for Noah and Paul to have their first kiss. I loved that their families were so accepting and I loved that they were able to go on dates. My affective response to this text is influenced by heteronormative narratives that I have read, seen, and digested for my whole life. We could honestly change the gender of either Paul or Noah and they could be a straight couple. I am trying hard to understand this queer utopia, and I love queer utopia when it is written by queer theorists like Jose Esteban Munoz, but this queer utopia is privileged and homonormative.
At one point I had to find out when this book was was written, and when I read 2003 I couldn't believe that the author still hasn't talked about HIV. I also couldn't believe that the book was so far behind for its time. Back in the 80s queer women of color were already doing publishing better work than this book. I tried to think of the potentials of writing a book where everyone is accepting, but should we be invested in a utopia where differences do not exist? I almost puked when I read that you couldn't tell gay clubs apart anymore because they were full of straight people. Not that I don't like straight people, but some spaces are created for specific reasons, especially in a world where everything is straight. I really dislike this author's "equality" rhetoric and can tell it was written by a gay white man. As I read details about the book and the author, he comments that he wanted to stay away from cliches. I want to challenge this idea, especially when he uses the common trope of the religious household in rural spaces. The rhetoric behind this trope makes it seem as if all rural spaces are homophobic, and all urban places are accepting; thus, one would accept the message that no violence occurs in larger cities, which is dangerous rhetoric. More importantly, I hate that I am loving the heteronormative narrative. I understand that this is a young adult novel, but sex is a big part of queer communities. We are known for cruising in the parks, the gay bathroom bump scene, and really, for loving our sexuality. Queer communities are very sex positive and while I enjoy the tongue in cheek humor (ex. straight people don't know how to dance), a lot of the radical queer politics of the time are missing. Sorry for the rant, it was just disappointing to read this white gay book and to enjoy at the same time. I will give it a B-.
At one point I had to find out when this book was was written, and when I read 2003 I couldn't believe that the author still hasn't talked about HIV. I also couldn't believe that the book was so far behind for its time. Back in the 80s queer women of color were already doing publishing better work than this book. I tried to think of the potentials of writing a book where everyone is accepting, but should we be invested in a utopia where differences do not exist? I almost puked when I read that you couldn't tell gay clubs apart anymore because they were full of straight people. Not that I don't like straight people, but some spaces are created for specific reasons, especially in a world where everything is straight. I really dislike this author's "equality" rhetoric and can tell it was written by a gay white man. As I read details about the book and the author, he comments that he wanted to stay away from cliches. I want to challenge this idea, especially when he uses the common trope of the religious household in rural spaces. The rhetoric behind this trope makes it seem as if all rural spaces are homophobic, and all urban places are accepting; thus, one would accept the message that no violence occurs in larger cities, which is dangerous rhetoric. More importantly, I hate that I am loving the heteronormative narrative. I understand that this is a young adult novel, but sex is a big part of queer communities. We are known for cruising in the parks, the gay bathroom bump scene, and really, for loving our sexuality. Queer communities are very sex positive and while I enjoy the tongue in cheek humor (ex. straight people don't know how to dance), a lot of the radical queer politics of the time are missing. Sorry for the rant, it was just disappointing to read this white gay book and to enjoy at the same time. I will give it a B-.
Monday, November 2, 2015
Unwind--meh
When I began to read this novel I was loving it. After all, it is fast paced, provides a dystopian world, and has an interesting plot. However, there were points where I had to question why I was enjoying this book so much. I even found myself hating the parents who would have their children unwound--this was when I began questioning the books motives. Being the pro-choice feminist that I am I asked myself why the author would make such an exaggerated version of "abortion." Certainly, we are supposed to empathize with the youth. We even empathize with the general towards the end of the novel. So I ask, why was it that Risa was always given a care taking role? She got the job of a medic, but she was also the person to take care of the baby, not Connor. Shusterman's male gaze relegate women to maternal roles and have readers empathize with the children; thus, the novel creates an exaggerated version of abortion and is highly relevant given the movements to defund planned parenthood. Even if I enjoyed the novel and cannot argue that it isn't interesting, my interest in Unwind cannot look past it's repronormative motives.
Tuesday, October 27, 2015
Feminist Killjoy: Violet
While reading Feed I was interested in the character portrayed by Violet and how she was treated by others. Her relationship with Titus reveals how privilege works in a consumerist society. Not only did Titus question her at first, but he was also angry at her refusal to stop questioning the world. One of my favorite scenes is where she argues with Titus about her own body and his response is to rely on science. When he defends a "progressive" view of science, she remarks: "Have you looked at the sea?" Titus' friends saw Violet as snobby, and even Titus' himself refuses to acknowledge Violets' awareness of the world in his last interactions with her. The character of Violet can be best described by what Sarah Ahmed calls a "feminist killjoy." Violet sees past the marketing techniques of feed as well as our reliance on "science." She even goes far enough to search Mayan spells; thus, alluding to the fall of an empire. In this case, Violet's social location has made her see the fall of nature as well as the fall of language, cultures, and biopolitical relations where some bodies have more value than others. All in all, Violet embodies the feminist killjoy who questions and angers those around her.
Tuesday, October 20, 2015
Good end
When I read the last half of Alexie's text I was focused on the interactions that jr had while at school. After his grandma died, it was jr's classmates who supported him when his teacher reprimanded him for not showing up to school. Ideally a school would communicate with the teachers when something bad happens in a student's life. However, a teacher should be looking out for signs that something is wrong and then let the student know that they have a safe space to talk if they choose. I liked that Alexie brought the strong community aspect of Rez life and admits that he is not in love with white people. There where times when I thought jr began to judge his own community, but towards the end we understand that jr knows his community has flaws, but he loves his community and knows why these flaws exist. Still further, I believe Alexie is a sexist and homophobe.
Monday, October 12, 2015
Great book, but not without its problems
While this has been by far my favorite book (yes, it beat Eleanor & Park), I do question some of the author's intentions. For one, Gabi refers to many authors, including: Sylvia Plath, Edgar Allan Poe, John Steinbeck, etc. However, only a few Latina authors, like Sandra Cisneros, where mentioned in Gabi's journey as a poet. This could be commentary on the lack of authors of color that students are exposed to while in high school, but Gabi's love for white authors ignores the lack of racial awareness in some these works.
Nevertheless, I throughly enjoyed Gabi's use of poetry in times of difficulty. Chicana feminism has repeatedly argued against the slut/virgin dichotomy presented in Latin@ cultures. Thus, Gabi's zine has the ability of mending the silences and shaming that Gabi has encountered. I also loved when Gabi recognizes that she is one of the "bad girls," and wish the authored would have explored polyamory--she obviously loves Martin, but there are times when Gabi cannot ignore the physical attraction she has for other boys.
Additionally, I'm not sure how I feel about Gabi as an LGBT ally. When Sebastian came out to her, she explained that there was no problem. But when she thought Cindy would come out, she said it would have been different. She also mentions that Sebastian joined the school's GSA, and that this was a good thing because she felt that she did not know enough about LGBT issues to be a good ally. I feel like a good friend, not just an ally, would try their best to be understanding and do their own research. I do appreciate that the author stayed away from the "it gets better" narrative that is commonly advertised towards LGBT youth. Sometimes it doesn't get better, and coming out could lead to being kicked out. So while this has been my favorite book, and I laughed, teared up, and was even angry at some parts, it is a book that has problems that cannot be overlooked.
Nevertheless, I throughly enjoyed Gabi's use of poetry in times of difficulty. Chicana feminism has repeatedly argued against the slut/virgin dichotomy presented in Latin@ cultures. Thus, Gabi's zine has the ability of mending the silences and shaming that Gabi has encountered. I also loved when Gabi recognizes that she is one of the "bad girls," and wish the authored would have explored polyamory--she obviously loves Martin, but there are times when Gabi cannot ignore the physical attraction she has for other boys.
Additionally, I'm not sure how I feel about Gabi as an LGBT ally. When Sebastian came out to her, she explained that there was no problem. But when she thought Cindy would come out, she said it would have been different. She also mentions that Sebastian joined the school's GSA, and that this was a good thing because she felt that she did not know enough about LGBT issues to be a good ally. I feel like a good friend, not just an ally, would try their best to be understanding and do their own research. I do appreciate that the author stayed away from the "it gets better" narrative that is commonly advertised towards LGBT youth. Sometimes it doesn't get better, and coming out could lead to being kicked out. So while this has been my favorite book, and I laughed, teared up, and was even angry at some parts, it is a book that has problems that cannot be overlooked.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)