Don't get me wrong--I am a sucker for romance. When Noah gives flowers to Paul I was the first to text my boyfriend and ask him where my flowers were at. However, and it is a big HOWEVER, I would never teach this book in tri-cities. Not because of the queer content, I wouldn't teach this book because I know my queer students would call me out for feeding them a white text. Where I'm from, we don't have parents who are dentists or nice houses with an art studio. Pasco High School has evacuations on a weekly basis because there is usually a shooting nearby. We have teachers who look away when they find pot, and we also have a gay club that is 90% Latin@. If I were to teach this book I would focus on Infinite Darlene and her gender transgressions. I'm not sure if she is transgender, and I like that. This is the only character I liked because she really fucks with gender. We usually hear of a transgender girl who is very femme and likes boys, but Infinite Darlene is different because she can be femme and she can also be a quarterback. In a way I thought she was genderqueer--haven't finished reading the book so I'm hoping the author works more with this concept. As I read this book I was excited for Noah and Paul to have their first kiss. I loved that their families were so accepting and I loved that they were able to go on dates. My affective response to this text is influenced by heteronormative narratives that I have read, seen, and digested for my whole life. We could honestly change the gender of either Paul or Noah and they could be a straight couple. I am trying hard to understand this queer utopia, and I love queer utopia when it is written by queer theorists like Jose Esteban Munoz, but this queer utopia is privileged and homonormative.
At one point I had to find out when this book was was written, and when I read 2003 I couldn't believe that the author still hasn't talked about HIV. I also couldn't believe that the book was so far behind for its time. Back in the 80s queer women of color were already doing publishing better work than this book. I tried to think of the potentials of writing a book where everyone is accepting, but should we be invested in a utopia where differences do not exist? I almost puked when I read that you couldn't tell gay clubs apart anymore because they were full of straight people. Not that I don't like straight people, but some spaces are created for specific reasons, especially in a world where everything is straight. I really dislike this author's "equality" rhetoric and can tell it was written by a gay white man. As I read details about the book and the author, he comments that he wanted to stay away from cliches. I want to challenge this idea, especially when he uses the common trope of the religious household in rural spaces. The rhetoric behind this trope makes it seem as if all rural spaces are homophobic, and all urban places are accepting; thus, one would accept the message that no violence occurs in larger cities, which is dangerous rhetoric. More importantly, I hate that I am loving the heteronormative narrative. I understand that this is a young adult novel, but sex is a big part of queer communities. We are known for cruising in the parks, the gay bathroom bump scene, and really, for loving our sexuality. Queer communities are very sex positive and while I enjoy the tongue in cheek humor (ex. straight people don't know how to dance), a lot of the radical queer politics of the time are missing. Sorry for the rant, it was just disappointing to read this white gay book and to enjoy at the same time. I will give it a B-.
No comments:
Post a Comment