Thursday, September 24, 2015
It doesn't get better
Reading Hanna's story and the reactions from her classmates to the tapes show's the victim blaming that occurs with suicide. At one point Hannah herself calls people "victim-blamers," and it is interesting to see Clay's reactions transform into empathy. One of my favorite sections to read was when Hannah explains what went through her mind as a guy grabbed her "ass." It made me disgusted to see the self-rightenousness that men feel with women's bodies, and I thought it was a necessary section for young adults to read. Events like the party with Courtney and the peeping Tom have real effects, which is what i found useful in the novel. When I was in high school I used to be a cutter and I remember one of my teachers recommending me to read The Perks of Being a Wallflower--which continues to be one of my favorite books. As an LGBT individual who belongs in that ugly statistic (LGBT youth attempting suicide) I can say that reading novels that deal with "shitty" subjects is necessary. It makes you feel like you are not the only one having these thoughts. For other students who might not have this experience, I would assume it creates empathy because it shows the many experiences that shape us. At the same time, I appreciated this novel coming from the stand point of someone who has already committed suicide. I feel like a lot of books focus on happiness and an "it gets better message," but sometimes it doesn't get better and this should be acknowledged.
Thursday, September 3, 2015
Eleanor and Park: Real Shit
While reading this novel I noticed that the author continues to have students call each other out for "racist" statements. These, I thought, were prejudiced statements, but I appreciated when Eleanor would talk about systemic racism--specifically when she made a comment on how F@#$ up it was that white kids went to honors classes and black kids were in mainstream classes. This novel took me back to my own young adult days and I was able to identify with Eleanor on terms of poverty and PE.
I think it is important to understand how PE is a dangerous space for many teenagers. In Eleanor's case, she was constantly harassed due to the physical nature of this class, and the fact that the other girls would use this class as an excuse to harass her in the locker rooms (bloody pads event). Meanwhile, I remember being verbally harassed in PE for my femininity and the fact that I would take the aerobics course with the female students. Some students made it obvious that my presence in the boys locker room made them uncomfortable.
For the most part, I think the book provided a realistic portrayal of poverty. One of my favorite quotes is when the author explains, "if she was going to cry about something, it was going to be the fact that her life was complete shit--not because some cool, cute guy didn't like her like that" (70). Many people view young adults as emotional beings that are only concerned with superficial "drama;"this quote, however, recognizes that some young adults deal with real shit and are not only moved by relationships. The book is not without its problems (Park's dad fetishizing the Korean mother), but it does open up discussions about poverty and being different while in High School.
I think it is important to understand how PE is a dangerous space for many teenagers. In Eleanor's case, she was constantly harassed due to the physical nature of this class, and the fact that the other girls would use this class as an excuse to harass her in the locker rooms (bloody pads event). Meanwhile, I remember being verbally harassed in PE for my femininity and the fact that I would take the aerobics course with the female students. Some students made it obvious that my presence in the boys locker room made them uncomfortable.
For the most part, I think the book provided a realistic portrayal of poverty. One of my favorite quotes is when the author explains, "if she was going to cry about something, it was going to be the fact that her life was complete shit--not because some cool, cute guy didn't like her like that" (70). Many people view young adults as emotional beings that are only concerned with superficial "drama;"this quote, however, recognizes that some young adults deal with real shit and are not only moved by relationships. The book is not without its problems (Park's dad fetishizing the Korean mother), but it does open up discussions about poverty and being different while in High School.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)