Monday, October 12, 2015

Great book, but not without its problems

While this has been by far my favorite book (yes, it beat Eleanor & Park), I do question some of the author's intentions. For one, Gabi refers to many authors, including: Sylvia Plath, Edgar Allan Poe, John Steinbeck, etc. However, only a few Latina authors, like Sandra Cisneros, where mentioned in Gabi's journey as a poet. This could be commentary on the lack of authors of color that students are exposed to while in high school, but Gabi's love for white authors ignores the lack of racial awareness in some these works.

Nevertheless, I throughly enjoyed Gabi's use of poetry in times of difficulty. Chicana feminism has repeatedly argued against the slut/virgin dichotomy presented in Latin@ cultures. Thus, Gabi's zine has the ability of mending the silences and shaming that Gabi has encountered. I also loved when Gabi recognizes that she is one of the "bad girls," and wish the authored would have explored polyamory--she obviously loves Martin, but there are times when Gabi cannot ignore the physical attraction she has for other boys.

Additionally, I'm not sure how I feel about Gabi as an LGBT ally. When Sebastian came out to her, she explained that there was no problem. But when she thought Cindy would come out, she said it would have been different. She also mentions that Sebastian joined the school's GSA, and that this was a good thing because she felt that she did not know enough about LGBT issues to be a good ally. I feel like a good friend, not just an ally, would try their best to be understanding and do their own research. I do appreciate that the author stayed away from the "it gets better" narrative that is commonly advertised towards LGBT youth. Sometimes it doesn't get better, and coming out could lead to being kicked out. So while this has been my favorite book, and I laughed, teared up, and was even angry at some parts, it is a book that has problems that cannot be overlooked.

No comments:

Post a Comment