A parenthetical comma or dash has a “highlighting”
effect when trying to point out small but important information. In the
following excerpt, I used a parenthetical dash to reinforce the white supremacist
nature of social institutions created through ideologies: “Ideologies and taxonomies have fought hard to oppress minorities –and
in this country – to wash out cultures and differences.” The main idea of
this sentence was to explain the power relations and inequalities found in ideologies;
not only do I achieve this purpose through a parenthetical dash, but I also
single out the way racisms works specifically
in the United States.
The
use of commas to organize lists washes out the individuality of these items—
however— the addition or exclusion of articles can add momentum to the lists. When
writing an essay about Chicana feminism, I wanted to introduce Gloria Anzaldúa
and used a list to capture the many topics found in her writing. When I first
wrote this list, I had not thought about the effect of excluding articles in
lists with commas, and when I made the correction I saw how it connects every
item in the list together. The list connects Anzaldúa’s writing themes to
Chicana liberation topics through the exclusion of articles when I write: “Gloria Anzaldúa (1942-2004) is one of the
many queer Chicana writers who calls for a new culture and follows Chicana
anti-imperialist, anti-patriarchy, mujerista, Chicana liberation topics.” Had
I kept the article “and” before the last item in the list, I dismiss all of the
items in between the list. Through a parenthetical comma I unite all of the
list items to the last topic in the list and give equal attention to every
item.
Audre Lorde was a distinct feminist in that she “came
out” in a critical time for the black and gay rights movement. She could have
chosen to fight for one movement but Lorde understood the importance of
embracing every aspect of your being. To identify one of her key teachings, I
use a reflexive pronoun in this sentence:
“Lorde herself calls upon women who are different to recognize all of their
differences and to treat them justly.” Besides the obvious power given to
Lorde with the reflexive pronoun, I emphasize the idea of Lorde coming out as a
black feminist lesbian writer alone.
Hi Ruben! I really want to say that I think all of what you wrote about here sounds really interesting--I will definitely have to look into some of the writers that you talk about!
ReplyDeleteAs for your grammar, I think what you did here was interesting. I think for your first sentence, perhaps parenthetical commas would work better, but I get what you're trying to do with the dashes. I think there is a way that you could reword the sentence and make the dash sound really natural.
I like your second sentence because it really shows how the lack of "and" in a list can have a rhetorical effect of really emphasizing the amount of items in the list, almost feeling as if they stack on top of one another.
Your third sentence was my favorite, and I think that's because the reflexive pronoun here has a few different operations and implications within the sentence. First, you are emphasizing that you are speaking about a specific person that calls others to "recognize differences....etc." However, I think another function that it has in the sentence is to show that Lorde herself exemplifies what she is calling upon other women to do.
Nice job!
Liza